Skip to content

From Save HPHS: Save Our Schools Edition

July 24, 2011


The following post  is from Steve Scanlon, formerly of Huntington Park High School.  It is a meditation on what has gone wrong with education and where we need to go from here in Los Angeles and all over the country. 

I think the line that stuck out for me was when he states that current education policy has alienated students from teachers and driven a wedge between administrators and teachers.  Honestly, two years ago, I couldn’t have imagined writing derogatory things about my former adminstrators but now I do because they kept me and other teachers from doing what we should be doing: authentic teaching. They reduced me and my students to “data” to a number with no regard for students talents or the needs of society.  They forcibly separated us from the schools we should be at and cast us adrift for literally no reason.  The students are alienated from us because we are forced to teach “standards” which often have no relevance and will not lead to any type of upward mobility since actual classes that teach skills have largely been stripped from our schools.  Today a “skill” is considered “inferencing” but how shall they apply it and in what setting?

My most promising seniors many of whom absolutely deserved the A grades they received from me are working in fast food restaurants. A few are in college, but not all the ones who should be there. And why should they go?  Tuition has just been raised another 12% while the college presidents get huge raises.  Many already have children or are pregnant.  They see limits, no horizons.   I try to let them know that those horizons exist, but there is  a curious silence when I bring that up.  One wants to buy a  house in Watts.  He has qualified for a loan.  Risking hurting his feelings I wrote to him that zip codes matter. They shouldn’t, but they do.  If you can qualify for an FHA loan, I said, why not consider Glendale or Burbank, areas with considerably better schools.  I had to do it, I would have been negligent had I not.  I flat out told him his son’s life chances depended on the education he receives and his parent’s involvement with that education;  and with the schools in LA being used as political spoils, life chances for all students are considerably diminished.   That’s not how it was supposed to be or how it used to be. At one time, Fremont High was one of the top three high schools in the STATE, yes the state of California- that was when they had a full music department and plenty of electives. It was also when our society had plenty of blue collar jobs for those not attending college.  Instead of outsourcing for the cheapest product our philosophy was to invest in our youth for the future.  That’s why Save Our Society is an apt title for Steve’s post- because the schools are just a symptom of the problem.  The cover stories of “bad teachers”   and “failing schools” are a smokescreen to allow outsourcing to spread to education,  in case anyone missed the article on high teacher turnover  at charter schools in the LA Times. We have become a country that caters to the lowest bidder.

Save our Society

Posted on July 24, 2011 by savehphs

I am sitting at a Days Inn in Virginia with my wife. It is Sunday, July 24 in Newport News, Virginia, a sweltering 90 degrees at 8:45 am. Vacation time? Sort of. My son is with the Marines to Japan and then points unknown. His departure date. Well that’s a secret for now. I’ll tell you later. His choice was to serve our country out of high school, and to do what was not easy, but what was hard, to become a United States Marine. My wife and I are pacifists by nature and didn’t like the thought of our little boy going off to a foreign land and running afoul of dangerous and unsympathetic people bent on killing him. I guess that’s blunt enough. But, as a man, he made that choice, and is now on a first phase of overseas deployment for some years to come.

What does this have to do with education in our nation? Everything. If it weren’t for this trip, I would have been planning a trip just a little farther north, to Washington D.C. where another group of patriots will be protesting the cavalier and erroneous national educational policies that are bringing grief and confusion to many cities across the United States. Los Angeles is just one of the many cities across this great nation suffering through a process of reform that simply doesn’t work. Coincidentally, the state of Virginia, where we find ourselves at this moment, is one of a growing number of states that is requesting relief from the Bush-Obama policies of No Child Left Behind. None of the counties in this state have met their NCLB goals, and all are in danger of reconstitution, re-jiggering, reconfiguration or mischief that will throw them into despair, misery and confusion and open the door to modern  carpetbaggers, Charter School operators, who will give it a try from another angle.

No. Virginia wants none of it, nor do we the teachers in California. Nor do the teachers who will be marching at the end of this month on the capital in a great show of force, stating the obvious, “Let us teach!”.

We have had enough! Teachers have woken up across this great nation of ours and are proclaiming that the pundits have just gotten it wrong. What a revelation! We need to have a voice in the process that controls education in this country. We have seen the effects of too much government in our schools. This may not be a popular point with many of us, but it is clear to many others, that the Federal and State governments have taken the democracy out of our schools by imposing solutions in the form of giant bureaucracies. Instead of allowing educators to make decisions about homework, academic standards, and discipline, they have taken a government issue rectal thermometer and plugged it into a computer to see how our teaching practices improve from moment to moment. The government has ignored the humanity of our profession, have put us on a treadmill, and have decided to measure our ability to teach by measuring student outcomes on badly written standardized tests. What the nation has discovered time and time again is that students in poor areas tend to perform on the whole worse than students in affluent areas. Does that surprise anyone?

There are no magic bullets, but there are policies that aggravate this process, that alienate the educators from the students and drive the administrators away from the teachers. The policies of high stakes competitive testing do all that and more.

Another revelation that has dawned upon many educational pundits of late, is that, when you make the test the most important thing, relevance goes out the window along with honesty, passion and learning. What is good teaching? Good learning, perhaps. Many of us believe that the product is more important than a test. I don’t teach a subject that is as easily measured by a standardized test, although there are certification programs that can measure students ability to be employable after taking my class. I like that sort of test. You see. I don’t believe that the size of the rubber mallet is effective when promoting learning. Not every student in Los Angeles is going to college. Let me say that again. Not every students in Los Angeles is going to college. Why should we pretend that is true? Every student is going to do something with his or her life, though. We should help them discover the best path for them, not the proscribed path of a pundit.

How do students learn? Primarily through curiosity, of course. If we are to save our society, we must embrace the love of that innate curiosity that makes our students, our children and those we love around us ask questions, not try to answer all of them with 85% comprehension on a timed test. In our time, nobody is the great provider of knowledge. There is too much to be learned, too many ways to go about it. What matters is productivity through the learning process. As the saying goes,”Life is a journey, not a destination.”. We as teachers must wrest that essential paradigm from those who would control us, dehumanize us and reduce us to flesh and blood laser pointers who point out the best probable response out of four. We are human. Our students are human, and we embrace humanity! We will not settle for less, because we are teachers. We will not let administrators and school board members who act out of fear and the need to placate pundits in Washington or Sacramento, reduce us to pawns in the educational process. We may not always know what makes students learn, but we do know this; if we don’t work together, share idealism, keep the greater good of our country in mind, and do all this with passion and conviction, we will not save our neighborhood schools, and in the process we will lose the faith and respect of those who need to know what is the right direction to turn to for their generation’s salvation. Stand up! Be proud! You are the light!

Make a contribution to the S.O.S. Cause. It is our own

No comments yet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: